Master Market Manipulation: Specific Manipulative Activities

Understanding market manipulation is pivotal in complying with securities regulations. This segment explores four specific manipulative activities: front running, marking the open/close, backing away, and freeriding. Each carries its unique rules and ethical considerations, imperative for the FINRA Securities Industry Essentials® (SIE®) Exam. Below, we provide detailed explanations, real-life examples, and integrative visuals to cement your understanding.

Front Running

Explanation

Front running is the unethical practice of a broker executing orders on a security for its own account while taking advantage of advance knowledge of pending orders from its customers. This action exploits non-public information regarding large transactions that could affect the security’s price.

Example

Consider a broker who is aware that a client intends to purchase a large number of shares of XYZ Corporation. Anticipating a price increase, the broker buys XYZ shares for their own portfolio before executing the client’s order. Once the client places their order and the share price rises, the broker benefits personally from the favorable price movement.

Regulatory Considerations

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) view front running as fraudulent and deceitful, subjecting offending brokers to severe penalties.

Visual Aid

    flowchart TD
	    A[Broker receives large client order] --> B[Broker buys shares]
	    B --> C[Client order executed]
	    C --> D[Stock price rises]
	    B --> E[Broker profits]

Summary Points:

• Front running involves using non-public information for personal gain.
• It is illegal and subject to enforcement action.
• Understanding the implications can help avoid penalties and ensure ethical practices.

Marking the Open/Close

Explanation

Marking the open or the close refers to the practice of manipulating stock prices at the opening or closing of the market to affect the stock’s price and, consequently, its market perception.

Example

A trader buys a large block of shares in the final minutes of trading to artificially inflate the price. This skewed closing price portrays misleadingly improved performance metrics for the stock in public perception, potentially influencing investor decisions.

Real-World Consequences

Manipulating opening or closing prices can alter investor impressions, affecting decisions and market stability. Regulatory bodies monitor such actions to maintain fair trading environments.

Visual Aid

    graph TD;
	    A(Trading Day) --> B(Market Close)
	    B -->|Manipulative Action| C(Artificial Price Increase)
	    C --> D(Investor Misperception)

Summary Points:

• Intentionally influencing opening/closing prices is unethical.
• Such actions may mislead investors.
• Compliance helps ensure market integrity.

Backing Away

Explanation

Backing away occurs when a market maker fails to honor a published bid or ask price, hindering orderly trading and adversely affecting market confidence.

Example

Imagine a market maker publishing an offer to buy shares at $50. When approached to execute a sale, the market maker declines to honor this price, disrupting the participant’s ability to trade based on the published information.

Impact on Market Integrity

Backing away disrupts trading operations, breaches trust among market participants, and can invite regulatory scrutiny for undermining market transparency.

Summary Points:

• Ensuring firm offers and bids builds trust.
• Transparency is key to market stability.
• Compliance prevents unwarranted legal scrutiny.

Freeriding

Explanation

Freeriding involves buying securities without paying for them initially, selling them before the purchase payment clears, and using proceeds from the sale to cover the original purchase price. This practice violates settlement rules and exposes brokers to financial risks.

Example

An investor places an order to buy shares but does not have immediate funds. They quickly sell the shares before the purchase payment is settled, using the sale proceeds to pay for the original purchase.

Risks and Penalties

Freeriding could lead to account restrictions and potentially damaging regulatory action, emphasizing the importance of education on proper trading protocols.

Summary Points:

• Freeriding undermines market stability.
• Violating settlement rules invites penalties.
• Ethical trading and settling ensure a reliable market.

Glossary

• Market Manipulation: Practices aimed at artificially affecting the price or volume of securities.
• Front Running: Trading on advance information about non-public large market orders.
• Marking the Open/Close: Manipulating securities prices at the open or close of the trading day.
• Backing Away: Failing to honor published buy/sell offers.
• Freeriding: Buying securities without sufficient funds to pay for them and selling them to cover the purchase cost.

Additional Resources

• “Securities Regulation in a Nutshell” - A compact guide, accessible for new entrants to the market.
• FINRA’s website www.finra.org for rules and regulations.
• SEC website www.sec.gov for news and updates on securities law.

FINRA Securities Industry Essentials® (SIE®) Exam Preparation Quizzes